These New York cities have the cleanest, safest drinking water based on EPA contaminant data, compliance records, and infrastructure quality. Residents in these areas enjoy some of the best tap water in the state.
The New York cities with the best tap water on EPA record are Buffalo (A, 98/100); Yonkers (A, 97/100); New York (C, 70/100), followed by Rochester (D, 67/100) and Syracuse (F, 29/100). Buffalo leads the state at 98/100 (Grade A), scored on EPA contaminant levels, five-year violation history, and lead results. See the full top 20 below.
Buffalo has the best water quality of any graded New York city, scoring 98/100 (Grade A) on EPA data. Its rating reflects low detected contaminant levels, a clean five-year violation record, and low Lead and Copper Rule 90th-percentile results.
Each city starts at 100 and loses points for real EPA findings about its water system: health-based violations in the last five years (SDWIS), its latest Lead and Copper Rule 90th-percentile result, PFAS detected in EPA UCMR5 monitoring, and 2012–2019 compliance samples near or above a limit. Letters follow fixed bands: A ≥90, B ≥80, C ≥70, D ≥60, F below 60. Cities we cannot match to an EPA system are not graded.
Even in top-rated cities, a filter can help with chlorine taste, lead added by older home plumbing, or extra protection for infants and immunocompromised residents. Match the filter to any contaminant still flagged for your city — our water filter guide pairs common contaminants with proven filtration methods.
No — it ranks near the bottom nationally. New York ranks #51 of 51 states for water quality, with its 5 graded cities averaging 72/100 against 87/100 across all graded U.S. cities (a small sample, so one system moves the average a lot). Its cleanest city, Buffalo (98/100, Grade A), is #357 of 1138 graded U.S. cities. The state rank is the mean EPA-based score of each state's graded cities; see every state on our all-states ranking and the national top 50 on our best-tap-water cities list.
By EPA records for New York's largest water systems: New York grades C (70/100, #3 of 5 graded New York cities) with no health-based EPA violations in the last five years; Buffalo grades A (98/100, #1 of 5 graded New York cities) with no health-based EPA violations in the last five years; Yonkers grades A (97/100, #2 of 5 graded New York cities) with no health-based EPA violations in the last five years; Rochester grades D (67/100, #4 of 5 graded New York cities) with 1 health-based EPA violation in the last five years. Grades lose points for health-based violations, lead 90th-percentile results, PFAS detections and 2012–2019 samples near a limit; each city report shows which applied. Lead from older home plumbing is not captured by any city grade.
The cities listed below meet or exceed all EPA water quality requirements and demonstrate consistently excellent performance in protecting public health through clean drinking water.
How the top 20 cities in New York are distributed by water quality grade
Click any city to see detailed water quality report including specific contaminants, test results, and filter recommendations.
| Rank | City | Score | Grade | Population Served | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Buffalo | 98/100 | A | 276,000 | View Report → |
2 | Yonkers | 97/100 | A | 211,569 | View Report → |
3 | New York | 70/100 | C | 8,271,000 | View Report → |
#4 | Rochester | 67/100 | D | 210,000 | View Report → |
#5 | Syracuse | 29/100 | F | 192,000 | View Report → |
The best-scoring systems above are often small. Here is how the 5 largest graded New York water systems score on the same EPA-based scale.
Cities with excellent water quality typically share several common characteristics that contribute to their high scores:
Clean aquifers, reservoirs, or rivers with minimal upstream contamination from agriculture or industry.
State-of-the-art water treatment plants with advanced filtration and disinfection technology.
Regular pipe replacement, system upgrades, and proactive maintenance to prevent contamination.
Few or no violations, with consistent adherence to Safe Drinking Water Act requirements.
Even in cities with excellent water quality, some residents choose to use water filters for:
The contaminants most often reported in New York water systems, and what removes them:
Where it comes from, how to test, and which filters are NSF 53 certified to remove it
Best filters for lead →What they are, the new EPA limits, and the filters proven to remove them
Best filters for PFAS →Complete water quality rankings for every city
Every graded New York city, best to worst, and the state's national rank
View water quality by county in New York
Contaminants found in New York water
Top 50 cities nationwide
#1 city from each state
New York is #51 of 51 — see every state
Side-by-side water quality comparison