4 cities ranked best to worst by EPA-record water quality score
Pittsburgh has the best tap water grade in Pennsylvania (A, 100/100); Philadelphia is lowest (D, 69/100). Overall, none of the 4 Pennsylvania systems we grade has a health-based EPA violation in the last five years, so the state's tap water is safe by EPA compliance records — 50% earn a B or better. Statewide, Pennsylvania ranks #43 of 51 states for water quality (average 84/100 vs 87 nationally) — see every state's rank. Nationally, Pennsylvania's highest-ranked city is Pittsburgh at #279 of 1138 graded US cities — see the US cities with the best tap water (top 10 and top 50).
This page ranks the 4 Pennsylvania cities whose water systems we have matched to EPA records. Every city starts at 100 points and loses points for health-based EPA violations in the last five years (SDWIS 2026Q2), its most recent Lead and Copper Rule 90th-percentile result, PFAS detected in EPA's 2023–2026 UCMR5 monitoring, and 2012–2019 compliance samples that averaged near or above a limit. Letters follow fixed bands (A ≥90, B ≥80, C ≥70, D ≥60, F below 60). Cities run from the highest score (Pittsburgh) down to the lowest (Philadelphia); ties are ordered by population served. See the full scoring methodology for every deduction and the data vintages.
An A or B grade points to water that consistently tests within federal safety limits, while a C suggests moderate issues worth watching and a D or F flags contaminants or compliance problems serious enough to act on. These grades describe system-level water leaving the treatment plant — they can't account for your home's own plumbing, so older houses with lead service lines or fixtures can add contaminants after the water arrives. For a contaminant-by-contaminant view, see the Pennsylvania contaminant breakdown or drill into the county-level rankings.
What the EPA service line inventory and our Pennsylvania guide say, beyond the scores.
This ranking covers 4 Pennsylvania cities. 4 of them are matched to an active EPA-registered community water system (PWSID). Those 4 systems report serving 2,624,001 people in EPA's Safe Drinking Water Information System (SDWIS).
Of all 4 cities Pennsylvania cities we can grade from EPA records, 2 cities (50%) grade B or better, 1 sit in the C range and 1 grade D or F. The average score is 84/100.
None of the 4 graded systems has a health-based EPA violation in the last five years; the 23 violations on file in that window are monitoring or reporting lapses.
4 cities have a Lead and Copper Rule 90th-percentile result from 2020 or later: 1 city at 5 ppb or more.
EPA's UCMR5 PFAS monitoring (2023–2026) covers 4 cities: PFAS were detected in 2 cities, and PFOA or PFOS reached EPA's 4 ppt limit in 2 cities.
Pittsburgh scores highest (100) and Philadelphia lowest (69), a 31-point spread.
The clearest hard data for Pennsylvania is EPA's service line inventory, updated 2026-08-18 (Q2 2026). 2,908 Pennsylvania systems inventoried 3,929,613 service lines: 65,295 confirmed lead plus 48,443 galvanized lines requiring replacement, spread across 173 systems. The bigger number is 2,057,908 lines (52%) whose material is still unknown — more than one line in four — and EPA treats unknown lines as possible lead until a utility verifies them.
Of the 4 city-linked Pennsylvania utilities with an inventory on file, 4 report at least one lead or galvanized-requiring-replacement line. The largest, PHILADELPHIA WATER DEPARTMENT (Philadelphia, 1,600,000 served), reports 16,805 lead lines and 1,777 galvanized requiring replacement.
Our Pennsylvania water guide flags lead, radium, trihalomethanes, and PFAS as the contaminants of regional concern. Lead (EPA action level 0.015 mg/L (15 ppb); health goal 0) harms brain development in children and raises blood pressure and kidney risk in adults; Radium (EPA MCL 5 pCi/L (combined radium-226/228)) increases cancer risk with long exposure; Disinfection byproducts (regulated as TTHM (80 ppb) and HAA5 (60 ppb)) are associated with increased cancer risk over long exposure; PFAS (EPA 2024 MCLs of 4.0 ppt for PFOA and PFOS) are linked to immune, developmental, liver and some cancer effects.
Source water explains a lot of the pattern in Pennsylvania. Disinfection byproducts are a surface-water signature: chlorine reacts with organic matter in rivers and reservoirs, so byproducts tend to run higher where systems chlorinate surface water. Radium is naturally occurring and tends to show up in groundwater, leaching from bedrock into aquifers rather than arriving from pollution. PFAS are tied to specific sites — industrial discharges, firefighting-foam use at airports and bases — rather than to geology, so contamination is local and can affect either source type. Lead is different again: it enters after treatment from service lines and household plumbing, which is why the inventory figures above matter more than plant-level results. The Consumer Confidence Report your Pennsylvania utility mails each year states whether your system draws surface water or groundwater.
| Contaminant | Federal limit | Cities elevated | Over limit | Highest reading | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Trihalomethanes | EPA MCL 0.080 mg/L (80 ppb) | 3 | 0 | Pittsburgh | Total Trihalomethanes is associated with liver, kidney and nervous-system effects and increased cancer risk over long exposure. |
| PFAS | EPA 2024 MCLs of 4.0 ppt for PFOA and PFOS | 2 | 2 | Philadelphia | PFAS are linked to immune, developmental, liver and some cancer effects. |
| Haloacetic Acids | EPA MCL 0.060 mg/L (60 ppb) for HAA5 | 1 | 0 | Philadelphia | Haloacetic Acids is associated with increased cancer risk over long exposure. |
Service line counts: EPA SDWIS Service Line Inventory, Q2 2026 snapshot (updated 2026-08-18). Limits: EPA National Primary Drinking Water Regulations.
How Pennsylvania's 4 cities are distributed by water quality grade
2 out of 4 cities meet or exceed a B grade for water quality
Sorted by water quality score from best to worst. Click any city for a detailed water quality report.
| Rank | City | Score | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pittsburgh | 100/100 | A |
| 2 | Erie | 90/100 | A |
| 3 | Allentown | 77/100 | C |
| #4 | Philadelphia | 69/100 | D |
Sources: EPA SDWIS/ECHO violations and Lead and Copper Rule results (2026Q2 extract), UCMR5 PFAS occurrence (2023–2026), SYR4 compliance samples (2012–2019). Rubric v2 — methodology.
Found your city above? These guides turn its grade into an action plan.
Pitcher vs. under-sink vs. reverse osmosis, matched to the contaminants reported in Pennsylvania systems.
Where it comes from, how to test, and which filters are NSF 53 certified to remove it
Best filters for lead →Taste, odor, trihalomethanes, and why a carbon filter handles them
EPA's inventory of lead pipes by water system — a risk these plant-level grades cannot capture.
Put a Pennsylvania city next to where you're moving from (or to) and see every contaminant head to head.
Matched to the contaminants most often reported in Pennsylvania water. Check your city's report above first; treat for what is actually there.
Compare pitcher, under-sink and reverse osmosis systems on the water filter guide. On a private well? EPA utility records don't cover wells, so start with water testing in Pennsylvania.
The best water quality in Pennsylvania is found in Pittsburgh with a score of 100/100 and a grade of A. This puts Pittsburgh among the top-performing cities in the country for drinking water safety.
The most concerning water quality is in Philadelphia scoring 69/100 with a grade of D. Residents may want to consider home water testing and filtration options.
1 city with D or F grades:
The statewide average score is 84/100, which is 3 points below the national average of 87/100. Over half (50%) of Pennsylvania cities score above the national average, though some areas face challenges.
None of the 4 graded Pennsylvania cities has a health-based EPA violation in the last five years — no system exceeded a federal contaminant limit or missed a required treatment step in that window.
See every contaminant tracked in Pennsylvania water, city by city →
1 Pennsylvania city has a D or F grade. Residents in those areas — and anyone wanting extra protection — should consider a certified water filter that removes the specific contaminants found in Pennsylvania water systems.
Best for Multi-Contaminant Removal
APEC Reverse Osmosis System
Removes lead, PFAS, arsenic, nitrates, fluoride & 99%+ of contaminants. NSF certified.
Check Price on AmazonBest Pitcher Filter (Renter-Friendly)
ZeroWater 10-Cup Filter Pitcher
NSF 53 certified to reduce lead and chromium. No installation — fill from the tap and pour.
Check Price on AmazonTreats Every Tap, Not Just One
Aquasana Whole-House Filter (WH-1000-B)
Reduces 97% of chlorine at the main line, so showers and appliances are covered too — a point-of-use filter never reaches them.
Check Price on AmazonFilters are heavy. A whole-house system ships on a pallet and an under-sink unit is awkward to carry — Prime covers the delivery free, and the first 30 days cost nothing.
Try Prime freeFree for 30 days, then renews at Amazon’s current Prime price unless cancelled. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
We may earn a commission when you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.
Two cities' EPA records side by side — grade, health-based violations, lead and PFAS — with a filter pick matched to the lower-scoring one.
Pittsburgh has the best water quality grade among the 4 Pennsylvania cities we can grade, with a score of 100/100 (grade A). Scores start at 100 and lose points for health-based EPA violations, lead 90th-percentile results, PFAS detections in EPA's UCMR5 monitoring and historical (2012–2019) readings near a limit.
Yes, for most residents, by EPA compliance records. 100% of the 2,624,001 people served by the 4 Pennsylvania systems we grade get water from a system with no health-based EPA violation in the last five years. Across the 4 Pennsylvania cities we grade from EPA records, the average score is 84/100 and 50% earn a B or better. None has a health-based EPA violation in the last five years. 1 city grades D or F (lowest: Philadelphia D); residents there should consider a certified filter matched to the finding on the city page. Lead from household plumbing is not captured by any city-level grade.
Pennsylvania ranks #43 of the 51 states we grade, with an average city score of 84/100 against a national average of 87/100. The state rank is the mean score of each state's graded cities from EPA records; within Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh ranks #1 of 4 cities.
By population served: Philadelphia grades D (69/100, #4 of 4); Pittsburgh grades A (100/100, #1 of 4); Erie grades A (90/100, #2 of 4); Allentown grades C (77/100, #3 of 4). Each city report lists the utility's violations, lead 90th-percentile result and PFAS results.
None of the 4 graded Pennsylvania cities has a health-based EPA violation in the last five years. A health-based violation means a system exceeded a federal limit or missed a required treatment step; it does not mean the water is unsafe today. Contaminants commonly reported in Pennsylvania water include lead, radium, trihalomethanes, pfas. Each city report lists the specific violations, lead 90th-percentile result and PFAS monitoring.
It depends on what is in your water, so start with your city's report above or a lab test. For the contaminants most often reported in Pennsylvania: lead — a carbon-block filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 for lead, or reverse osmosis (NSF/ANSI 58); radium and uranium — reverse osmosis, or an ion-exchange system rated for radionuclides; chlorine and disinfection byproducts — activated carbon (NSF/ANSI 42 for taste and odor, NSF/ANSI 53 for trihalomethanes); pfas — reverse osmosis, or a carbon filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 or 58 for PFOA/PFOS; bacteria — UV disinfection (NSF/ANSI 55), mainly a private-well concern. On city water, an under-sink reverse osmosis system covers the widest range of these. Private-well households should test first, because utilities' EPA records do not cover wells.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania's largest graded water system (1,600,000 people served), grades D at 69/100 and ranks #4 of 4 Pennsylvania cities. The top-ranked Pennsylvania city is Pittsburgh (A, 100/100). It has no health-based EPA violations in the last five years. Among the 57 big US cities whose main system serves 500,000+ people, Philadelphia ranks #54. Grades come from EPA violation records, lead 90th-percentile results and PFAS monitoring, not from taste tests.
Of the 4 graded Pennsylvania cities, 1 city has a D or F grade. Another 1 city falls in the C range. 2 of 4 (50%) score above the national average of 87/100 across all graded U.S. cities in our dataset.
This page ranks 4 Pennsylvania cities from EPA's Safe Drinking Water Information System (violations and lead results, 2026Q2), UCMR5 PFAS monitoring (2023–2026) and Six-Year Review sample data (2012–2019). Each city link opens a report with the utility's violation history, lead 90th-percentile results and PFAS table. For official Consumer Confidence Reports (CCR), contact your local water utility — federal law requires all community water systems to deliver an annual CCR to customers. The Pennsylvania state environmental agency and the EPA's Safe Drinking Water Information System (SDWIS) also publish official water quality data.
State water quality summary and key statistics
Top 20 cities with the cleanest water
Top-ranked cities nationwide
Cities with the most concerning water
Compare water quality across all 50 states
Side-by-side water quality comparison
Which contaminants show up in Pennsylvania water
Certified filters matched to your contaminants